WELCOME TO THE CO-OP HOUSING INFORMATION EXCHANGE ("CHIE")

YOU CAN SCROLL DOWN AND FIND BLOGS THAT MAY HAVE BEEN PROVIDED IN A LINK FOR YOU ON TWITTER...OR BY E-MAIL. IN THE FAR RIGHT COLUMN OF EACH PAGE YOU CAN TRANSLATE A PAGE INTO A LANGUAGE THAT YOU PREFER BY CLICKING THE TRANSLATE BUTTON AND ALSO VIEW A PAGE MENU FOR THIS SITE.

WELCOME TO THE NEW CO-OP HOUSING INFORMATION EXCHANGE THAT HAS A MANDATE TO SHARE FREE INFORMATION ABOUT CO-OPS, SOCIAL/COMMUNITY HOUSING, AND RESOURCES IN CANADA, UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, UNITED KINGDOM, AND OTHER COUNTRIES.

WHAT MUST BE REQUIRED IS PRINCIPLED LEADERSHIP, GOOD GOVERNANCE AND MANAGEMENT THAT INCLUDE ACCOUNTABILITY AT ALL NON-PROFIT HOUSING CO-OPERATIVES ACROSS CANADA, AROUND THE WORLD, AND ANYTHING LESS THAN THAT SHOULD NOT BE ACCEPTABLE.

CO-OPERATION CAN LEAD TO SUCCESS THROUGH SHARING FREE KNOWLEDGE, LEARNING AND THEN UNDERSTANDING!

CHIE HELPS PUT TOGETHER ALL THE PIECES OF THE PUZZLE ABOUT NON-PROFIT CO-OP HOUSING IN CANADA, SO YOU CAN GAIN A BETTER PERSPECTIVE.
THE CULTURE OF SILENCE AT MEMBER CO-OPS NEEDS TO END THAT SURROUND THE PRACTICE OF POOR OR BAD GOVERNANCE AND MANAGEMENT.

FOLLOW YOUR CHIE, NOT A FAILED STATUS QUO WITH SELF-SERVING CO-OP HOUSING STAKEHOLDERS.

CHIE IS A SELF-HELP SITE THAT IS YOURS TO DISCOVER. LEARN ABOUT AND ADOPT PRINCIPLED LEARDERSHIP, GOOD GOVERNANCE AND MANAGEMENT PRACTICES. REVIEW INTERNAL CONTROLS, FRAUD DETECTION AND PREVENTION. LEARN ABOUT CO-OP STAKEHOLDERS, GOVERNING LAWS, AND NEWS MEDIA.

YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO EXPLORE MULTIBLE LINKS AREA AND ITEMS OF LEGISLATION THAT OFFER RESOURCES THAT MAY PROVIDE SOME SOLUTIONS FOR CANADIAN NON-PROFIT HOUSING CO-OPS AND NON-PROFIT HOUSING OUTSIDE CANADA IN DIFFICULTY OR CRISIS.

YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO RESEARCH CO-OP STAKEHOLDERS, GOVERNMENT AGENCIES, AND LEGISLATION THAT RELATE TO CO-OP'S IN YOUR PROVENCE OR STATE, AND COUNTRY. CHECK FOR INFORMATION UPDATES IN THE LINKS AREA AND OTHER LOCATIONS ON THE CHIE SITE.

IF YOU CAN'T FIND THE INFORMATION YOU ARE RESEARCHING ON CHIE OR KEN'S SITE, TRY SOME OF THE MANY LINKS AVAILABLE, EXAMPLE: CHF CANADA...

YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE A MEMBER TO FOLLOW YOUR CHIE!... BUT REGISTERED USERS THAT INCLUDE OPEN ID CAN POST COMMENTS ON CHIE.
**AS AT MARCH 2, 2014 YOU CAN NOW REGISTER AND JOIN THE CHIE SITE**

CHIE HAS A POLICY TO REVIEW AND DELETE MATERIAL OR COMMENTS THAT ARE DEEMED INAPPROPRIATE OR OFFENSIVE AT THE DISCRETION OF THE SITE ADMINISTRATOR. THE CHIE ADMINISTRATOR WILL NOT BE RESPONDING TO YOUR QUESTIONS OR ENQUIRES...

CO-OP AND SOCIAL HOUSING RESIDENTS ARE ENCOURAGED TO START THEIR OWN SOCIAL NETWORKING SITE, AND COMMUNICATE INFORMATION TO YOUR FELLOW RESIDENTS ABOUT CONCERNS WITH GOVERNANCE AND MANAGEMENT OR NOT DEMOCRATICALLY RUN WHERE RESIDENT VIEWS AND OPINIONS ARE SILENCED. EXAMPLES OF SOCIAL NETWORK SITES INCLUDE BLOGGER, TWITTER, WORDPRESS, AND FACEBOOK, ETC...REMEMBER, FOLLOW YOUR CHIE!

SHARE YOUR STORIES WITH CHIE ABOUT CO-OP HOUSING BY USING THE CONTACT INFORMATION BELOW, AND IT MAY BE PUBLISHED ON THE CHIE SITE.

NOTICE ABOUT CHIE CONTENT AS AT JULY 16, 2017
SOME INFORMATION HAS BEEN TAKEN OUT OF VIEW FOR FURTHER REVIEW AND MAY BE RE-PUBLISHED A LATER POINT IN-TIME AFTER THE REVIEW HAS BEEN COMPLETED AND APPROVED


Ken Hummel, Administrator, Co-op Housing Information Exchange


Contact information, e-mail: <kenhummel@msn.com>




Showing posts with label CO-OP WATCH. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CO-OP WATCH. Show all posts

Wednesday

IN THE MATTER OF THORNHILL GREEN CO-OPERATIVE HOMES

SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO (Divisional Court); Court File No. 493/08; Date: 2009-02-11


Between: Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada And Thornhill Green Co-operative Homes Inc. (Applicants) - and -The Regional Municipality of York And Housing York Inc. (Respondent)


Before the Hon. Justice MacDonald, Wilson and Bellamy 

[93] "We do conclude, though, that the Region owed a duty of procedural fairness to the Co-op, despite the receivership."


[96] "We, therefore, dismiss the motion to quash the Region's consent to the sale of the Co-op under s. 95 of the SHRA."


[99] "For the above reasons, the application to quash the s.95 consent is dismissed."


Review all 19-pages or 101 paragraphs of the Court reulings:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/6z6zpns


SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO (Commercial List). Court File No. 07-CL-7044; Date: 2009-07-16


Between: The Regional Municipality of York (Applicant) - and - Thornhill Green Co-operative Homes Inc. (Respondent). In the matter of an application under section 116(1) 6 of the Social Housing Reform Act, 2000, S.O. 2000, c. 27


Before the Hon. Justice Morawetz

Justice Morawetz decisions and the proceedings are noted in the following paragraphs in whole or in part, below:


[55] "Even with the passage of time from the hearing of this motion, the view of the Receiver has not altered its view as can be seen from paragraphs 24-27 of its submissions filed on April 8, 2009: 24. "The respondents have opposed the Receiver's motion,..." "Yet, in all this, they have failed to address the basic problem facing this co-operative, namely, that it was unable to properly manage Thornhill Green and its financial affairs. Further, they have failed to come up with any solution to the fact that there is a great deal of capital work remaining to be done to ensure that the property does not deteriorate further, and the co-operative has no funds with which to do the work."


25. "The respondents postulate that, given further time, the parties may be able to work out a solution together. However, to date, they have not come forward with any solutions. Further, given the amount of time that has already passed, it is not clear when the respondents believe that they will be able to come up with such a solution, and noting has been provided to the Receiver in that regards."


26. "Further, the Receiver has brought a motion to this Honourable Court. The receiver has requested a decision from this Honourable Court." "The Receivership must be brought to an end to bring stability to the housing project and its residents, but there needs to be a sustainable long-term solution in place before this can occur."


27. "In the Receiver's view, the only viable solution to the ongoing and longstanding problems of Thornhill Green remains the transfer of the housing to HYI."


[71] "I am satisfied that the Receiver has acted fairly and diligently in carrying out its activities during the appointment and, in particular, the sales process. In my view, the Receiver has acted in accordance with Soundair principles set out above."


[74] "The inescapable conclusion is that the co-operative governance model of Thornhill Green has not worked as envisioned. In my view, an operational change is necessary."


[78] "Although there will be an impact in the change in status on residents, it must be recognized that the status quo has not worked and change is necessary. The proposed change is, in these circumstances, fair, reasonable and equitable."


Review all 15-pages or 81 paragraphs of the Court rulings:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/458teze


COST ENDORSEMENT

[6] "Costs are awarded in favour of the Region on a partial-indemnity basis in the amount of $15,000 inclusive of GST and disbursements, payable by Thornhill Green and CHFC."


Review all 2-pages or 6 paragraphs of the Court rulings and in respect to cost endorsment:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/48meo4g


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review Court Files and Case Information in regards to Thornhill Green Co-operative Homes Inc. 

DELOITTE.COM

http://tinyurl.com/4mea8ao


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CHF Canada, Ontario Region media release's:

January 7, 2011

"Supreme Court turns down Thornhill Green's appeal request"


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/4erku4p


June 2, 2010

"Ontario Court of Appeal Allows York Region Takeover of Thornhill Green Co-op."


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/4aah3ks


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review Some Other News Media coverage about Thornhill Green Co-operative Homes Inc.:


YORKREGION.COM

September 9, 2010

By David Fleischer

"Thornhill co-op residents appeal to supreme court"

http://tinyurl.com/4jseyk6


YORKREGION.COM

June 10, 2010

By David Fleischer

"Appeals court rules against co-op"

http://tinyurl.com/4rghhbx


Thornhill Green Co-op - Court of Appeals Ruling (York Region First Local). Click link below to watch 1:59 Video:


June 2, 2010

http://youtube.com/watch?v=eKb6wefNEFk



Information noted above may be revised and/or deleted without prior notification.



Ken Hummel, Administrator, CHIE


IN THE MATTER OF MATTHEW WAY CO-OPERATIVE HOMES

Review news media update on the former housing co-op, Matthew Way:


theenterprisebulletin.com

August 15, 2014

By Morgan Ian Adams, Enterprise-Builletin

"County changes name, direction, for former co-op housing project"

CLICK HERE



SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO - Court File No. CV-07-0319 and CV-10-0139 - Date: 2011-02-25 - Heard: February 25, 2011


In the matter of an application under section 120(9) of the Social Housing Reform Act, 2000, and section 101 of the Courts of Justice Act and Rules 14.05(2) and (3)(h) of the Rules of Civil Procedure.


Between: The Corporation of the County of Simcoe (Applicant) -and- Matthew Co-operative Housing Inc. (Respondent) -and- The Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada (Intervener)


Before the Hon. Justice P.D. Lauwers

ENDORSMENT

[22] "The Receiver will produce the material required in this decision at no cost to the Board of Matthew Co-operative and CHFC."


[23] "In ordering the production of this material in un-redacted form, I am exercising my authority under section 64 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act, R.S.O. 1990 cF.31 and section 7(3) of the Personal Information, Protection and Electronic Documents Act, S.S. 2000 c.5 and Schedule 1, clause 4.5. The members of the Board will continue to be bound by their confidentiality undertakings and the confidentiality provisions of the Social Housing Reform Act 2000, S.O. 2000 c.27."...


Review all 5-pages or 25 paragraphs of the Court rulings:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/6wocnqh



SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO - Court File No.: CV-07-0319, CV-10-0139 and CV-10-0139 - Date: 2010-07-15 - Heard: April 15-16, 2010


Application under section 120(9) of the Social Housing Reform Act, 2000, section 101 of the Courts of Justice Act and Rules 14.05(2) and (3) (h) of the Rules of Civil Procedure


Between: The Corporation of the County of Simcoe (Applicant) -and- Matthew Co-operative Housing Inc. (Respondent) -And Between: Matthew Co-operative Homes Inc. (Applicant) -and- The Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada (Intervener)


Before the Hon. Justice Lauwers

REASONS FOR DECISIONS

[128] "The receiver and the County have failed to persuade me on the evidence that the board lacks the capacity to resume governance with appropriate training and mentoring."


[129] "Matthew Co-Op and CHFC submit that the financial situation for Matthew Co-Op is not urgent. The Policy goals in the CCA and the SHRA, together with the unfairness of the process leading to the County of Simcoe's approval of the sale of the assets militate against court approving the sale of the assets of Matthew Co-Op and in favour of returning governance to the board. They argue that governance should be returned to the board, and if Matthew Co-Op fails again, then the County of Simcoe has a clear remedial path under the SHRA that it can take at that time without seriously endangering its financial position in the meantime."


[130] "In these motions the Receiver and the County of Simcoe unsuccessfully pursued approval of the sale and the vesting order. They did not respond in any detail to the governance transition plan proposed by the Board of Matthew Co-Op and CHFC that would see governance eventually resumed by the Board. I am not prepared to consider such a plan without the advice of the Receiver and County, and further evidence and submissions."


[131] "I direct the parties to arrange a date before the end of September 2010 with the trial co-ordinator for additional submissions on the appropriate next steps."


Review all 29-pages or 132 paragraphs of the Court decision:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/6hw2php


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


CHF Canada, Ontario Region media release's:

December 10, 2010

"Matthew co-op wins legal fight against takeover"


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/4rnapr8


July 16, 2010

"Court prevents takeover of Matthew Co-op by Simcoe County"


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/5utffff


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Review some other news media coverage, re: Matthew Way Co-operative Homes:



THEBARRIEEXAMINER.COM

August 11, 2011

"Co-op housing blaze causes $100,000 damage"

http://tinyurl.com/3mltgsm


THEENTERPRISEBULLETIN.COM

In or about 2009

By Sharon Weatherall

"Matthew Way fire kills woman"

http://tinyurl.com/3mow24m


SIMCOE.COM

May 14, 2009

By Laurie Watt

"Co-op ask county not to sell"---"Matthew Way Co-operative is appealing to Simcoe County not sell the 80-unit development"

http://tinyurl.com/4abvje3


SIMCOE.COM

November 26, 2008

By John Edwards, Staff

"County endorses sale of Matthew Way Co-op"

http://tinyurl.com/4hx9jpz


SIMCOE.COM

October 10, 2007

By Laurie Watt

"co-op repairs require county money"

http://tinyurl.com/4tqrf6h


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Some Additional Background Information:

Town of Collingwood Council Agenda dated November 2, 2009 & Council Minutes dated October 26, 2009 includes Collingwood's Affordable Housing Task Force Minutes of October 13, 2009. Discussion in the minutes in regards to Matthew Way Co-operative Homes can be reviewed on pages 14, 15, 16, and 17 of the 118-pages noted.


Click link to view the discussion:

http://tinyurl.com/67az5kq




Information noted above may be revised and/or deleted without prior notification.




Ken Hummel, Administrator, CHIE





IN THE MATTER OF LABOURVIEW CO-OPERATIVE HOMES

SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO - Divisional Court - Court File No.: 135/07 - Date: 2007-08-13 - Heard: May 28, 2007


Between: Labourview Co-operative Homes Inc. and Krista Burk (Applicants) - and- The Corporation of the Municipality of Chatham-Kent and Horwath Orenstein Inc., in its capacity as a Receiver and Manager of Labourview Co-operative Homes Inc. (Respondents)


Before the Hon. Justice Lane, Jennings And Brockenshire  

BY THE COURT:

[38] "For these reasons, we conclude that, no "triggering event" having occurred, Chatham-Kent had no jurisdiction to intervene in the management of the Labourview Co-operative, and its decision to do so must be quashed In view of this decision, it is not necessary to consider the other grounds raised by the applicants, based on whether the receivership was a reasonable response to the facts, and whether the rules of procedural fairness were breached."


DECISION

[39] "We grant the application for judicial review, and as requested grant an order: i) quashing the decision made by Chatham-Kent to appoint the receiver over Labourview pursuant to s. 116(1) of the SHRA; ii) declaring that a receiver and manager over Labourview is not justified under the SHRA and discharging the receiver."


Please note that the 10-page or 39 paragraph Court decision can't be reviewed at CanLii.org at this point-in-time.



SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO - Divisional Court - Court File No.: 135/07 - Date: 2008-11-14


Between: Labourview Co-operative Homes Inc. and Krista Burk (Applicants) -and- The Corporation of the Municipality of Chatham-Kent and Horwath Orenstein Inc., in its capacity as Receiver and Manager of Labourview Co-operative Homes Inc. (Respondents)


Before the Hon. Justice Jennings And Brockenshire

BY THE COURT


DECISION ON COSTS


Review all 6-pages or 13 paragraphs of the Court decision:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/6xkjzy9


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CHF Canada media release

August 31, 2005

"The Co-op was put in recievership by the Chatham-Kent service manager in October 2006. The reason given for the recievership was that the co-op had an "accumulated deficit that was material and excessive having regard to the normal practices of similar providers." This is a "triggering event" (grounds for action) under the Social Housing Reform Act."


"In a unanimous decision issued on August 13 three judges in Ontario's Divisional Court quashed the recievership and granted an order "declaring that a reciever or a reciever and manager over Labourview is not justified under the SHRA and discharging the reciever". The decision put an immediate end to the recievership."


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/3kdq8xb




Information noted above may be revised and/or deleted without prior notification




Ken Hummel, Administrator, CHIE

IN THE MATTER OF BRIDLEWOOD CO-OPERATIVE HOMES

Review some news media report updates about the former housing co-op, Bridlewood:

sxfreepress.com July 18, 2013 "Letter to the Editor - On Bridlewood Co-op"

CLICK HERE


sxfreepress.com July 11, 2013 By Fred Groves

"Still lots of vacancies at former Bridlewood co-op"

CLICK HERE


sxfreepress.com October 25, 2012 By Fred Groves

"Bridlewood sold - Rent increased to $875"

CLICK HERE 

 

View the Essex Non-Profit Homes Inc. website :: CLICK HERE 

 

I posted a comment on the Essex Non-Profit Homes Inc. website on September 10, 2014 inquiring if Essex Non-Profit Homes would transition back to the co-op housing model and return to the status of non-profit co-op housing. My comment was awaiting moderation and was never published on their website! View my comment HERE !!!


SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO Commercial List: Court File No.: CV-11-9239-00CL - Heard: October 16, 2012


Between: Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada (Applicant) -and- Bridlewood Co-operative Inc., Superintedent of Financial Services, and United Communities Credit Union Limited (Respondants)


Before the Hon. D. M. Brown

[2] "For the reasons set out below, I grant the Receiver's motion and approve the HPNP sale transaction."


Review all 50 paragraphs of the Court ruling:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/bmefdao     



SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO Commercial List: Court File No.: CV-11-9239-00CL - Heard: June 21, 2011


Between: Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada (Applicant) -and- Bridlewood Co-operative Inc., Superintendent of Financial Services, and United Communities Credit Union Limited (Respondents)


Before the Hon. Justice Newbould

[21] "In the circumstances, Meyers Norris Penny Limited is appointed as receiver and manager of the assets of Bridlewood, to report to the court as soon as possible as to the approprite steps to be taken to wind up Bridlewood. There are to be no raises in the occupancy costs without further court order."


[22] "The parties are agreed that the costs of this application are to be dealt with after the reciever and manager reports back to the court."


Review all 9-pages or 22 paragraphs of the Court ruling:

CANLII.ORG

http://tinyurl.com/7btkv28



Review all 17-pages or 31 paragraphs of the Court Order Appointing Receiver and Manager:

MNPDEBT.CA

http://tinyurl.com/7s8knpj


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


Review the Receiver's Ninth Status Update to Members of Bridlewood Co-operative Inc. (2-pages):

MNPDEBT.CA

http://tinyurl.com/d37jqdw


Review Court documents and other documents in regards to Bridlewood Co-operative Inc.:

MNPDEBT.CA

http://tinyurl.com/74zbenl



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review some media reports about Bridlewood Co-op:


WINDSORSTAR.COM

July 31, 2012

Posted by Brian Cross

"Essex co-op housing project being sold off by receiver"

http://tinyurl.com/clge5ev



CHF Canada media release:

Some excerpt's from a June 29, 2011 eNEWS notification

CHF Canada eNEWS


June 29, 2011

"CHF Canada wins another round in fight to protect housing co-op assets"

"At CHF Canada's request, the Ontario Superior Court has appointed a receiver-manager for Bridlewood Housing co-op in Essex, Ontario, preventing the co-op's members from purchasing their units at discounted prices."


"Bridlewood is a 131-unit non-profit housing co-operative. It was developed in the mid-1970s with federal government funding. For the past 15 years this co-op has attempted by various means to sell the units for the personal benefit of members at considerably less than market value. Most recently, the co-op stopped paying its mortgage, and CHF Canada believed that this could be part of a plan to force its lender to foreclose and sell the properties in bulk at a discount."


..."Working with the lending credit union and the Financial Services Commission of Ontario (which oversees the Co-op Act), CHF Canada succeeded in safeguarding Bridlewood's assets by removing control from its board and members. A receiver will assess the co-op's situation and report back to the court with recommendations."...


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/6j5qc8

________________________________________________

________________________________________________


Review additional background information in regards to Bridlewood Co-op Inc. in the following excerpt's from an April 8, 2005 media release and excerpt's from the Court rulings.


CHF Canada media release

April 8, 2005

"Sale of housing co-op halted by court decision"

..."Mr. Justice Siegel's decision that the sale of the co-op's units to the members at less than half the market value is not allowed under the Co-operative Corporations Act."...


"The Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada had launched an application to hault the sale, along with Mr. Skinner, who lived in the co-op"..."The Financial Services Commission of Ontario (FSCO) also brought an application to stop the sale. FSCO's responsibilities include enforcing compliance with the CCA."


..."In 2003, the members decided to investigate the sale of the homes to the members who currently occupy them, at prices considerably less than their fair market value."...

"Mr. Justice Siegel, in an Ontario Superior Court decision on April 5, concluded that "as the Bridlewood proposal contemplates a sale to the members of property of the co-op at less than its fair market value, if implemented, the proposal would constitute a 'distribution' for the purposes of section 171.2(1) of the CCA." The Co-operative Corporations Act prohibits distribution of the assets of a non-profit housing co-operative to the co-op's members."


Click link to access additional information:

CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/5v4errt


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO - Court File No.: 04-CV-280686 and Court File No.: 04-CV-278076CM2; Date: 2005-06-29


Between: Bridlewood Co-operative Inc. v. Superintendent of Financial Services -and- The Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada - and - Ken Skinner v. Bridlewood Co-operative Inc.


Before the Hon. Justice H.J.W. Siegel

2005 CarswellOnt 2405 (57 paragraphs) Court decision that is not found at CanLii.org at this point-in-time. Please note an excerpt from the 57 paragraph Court decision:


[50] "Similary, the Occupancy Agreement must be interpreted in the light of the provisions of section 171.2(1) of the CCA. If there are two possible interpretations of the Occupancy Agreement, the Court should give effect to the interpretation that does not contravene the CCA. Bridlewood says quite frankly that it is proceeding on the basis that it owns only a "reversionary interest" in the homes because it has given the value of the occupancy rights to its member occupants. This is a clear acknowledgement that under its interpretation of the Occupancy Agreement, Bridlewood believes that it has disposed of property of value to its members. If the Co-op were correct in its interpretation, the grant of occupancy rights would contravene the prohibition in section 171.2(1) of the CCA against the disposition of property of the Co-op to its members. I conclude, however, that the Occupancy Agreement should be interpreted more narrowly to provide for a concept of occupancy rights that excludes such a distribution."


Or access the Court file noted above and review the 57 paragraph Court decision at the following website:

KLIPPENSTEINS.CA

http://tinyurl.com/77l8ddt


SUPERIOR COURT OF JUSTICE - ONTARIO - Court File No.: 04-CV-280686 and 04-CV-278076CM2 - Date: 2005-06-29 - Heard: March 1, 2005


Bridlewood Co-operative Inc v. Superintendent of Financial Services - and re - Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada - and - Ken Skinner v. Bridlewood Co-operative Inc.


Before the Hon. Justice H.J.W Siegel  

"SUPPLEMENTARY ENDORSEMENT"

[1] "The Endorsement dated April 5, 2005 in this proceeding contemplated a cost award after the receipt of cost submissions. Subsequently, counsel for Bridlewood Co-operative Inc. advised the Court that the parties have agreed there shall be no order as to costs and have requested a supplementary endorsement to this effect."


[2] "Accordingly, on the consent of the parties, shere shall be no order as to costs in this proceeding."


Review 1-page or 2 paragraphs of the Court decision: 

CANLII.ORG

http://www.tinyurl.com/3z7x9qz




Information noted above may be revised and/or deleted without prior notification.



Ken Hummel, Administrator, CHIE


IN THE MATTER OF NORTH END UNITED HOUSING CO-OPERATIVE LIMITED

North End United Housing Co-operative: 

CBC.CA

September 4, 2012

"Halifax co-op going into receivership"

http://www.tinyurl.com/9r88pko


METRONEWS.CA

August 28, 2012

By Ruth Davenport, Metro Halifax

"Halifax housing co-op heading into receivership"

http://www.tinyurl.com/8egvqm4



MONITOR'S Fifth Report to Court - July 24, 2012

Conclusion And Reommendations:


"NEU's Amended Plan has been rejected by the unsecured creditors and therefore the Amended Plan in its entirety has been rejected."


"Based on the considerations outlined in this Fifth Report, the Monitor respectfully recommends that:"

* "the Stay of Proceedings which expires on July 30, 2012 not be extended; and"

* "that the secured creditor proceed to enforce security."


Review all 144-pages of the Report in link below:


GRANTTHORNTON.CA

http://www.tinyurl.com/c8kh7zv


SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA - Court File: Hfx No. 374606 - Date: 02-07-2012


In The Matter Of: The Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-36, as amended


In The Matter Of: A Plan of Compromise or Arrangement of North End United Housing Co-operative Ltd., a body corporate under the laws of the Province of Nova Scotia


Before The Hon. Justice McDougall In Chambers


ORDER


2. "The Monitor's First Report is hereby approved."


3. "The Company is hereby authorized and empowered to enter into an arrangement to obtain a credit facility (the "DIP Facility") from Nova Scotia Housing Development Corporation (the "DIP Lender") in the maximum total principal amount of $250,000.00, substantially on the terms and conditions set forth in the letter dated January 30, 2012 between the DIP Lender and the Company, as such agreement may from time to time hereafter be amended by the parties thereto, with the consent of the Monitor and approval of the Court (the "DIP Commitment Letter"), to fund the ongoing, ordinary course of activities of the Company and to permit the Company to pay such amounts as may be permitted by the terms of this Order, the Initial Order, and the DIP Commitment Letter."


Review all 5-pages or 20 paragraphs of the Court decision:

GRANTTHORNTON.CA

http://www.tinyurl.com/7xg9us2



SUPREME COURT OF NOVA SCOTIA - Court File: Hfx No. 374606 - Date: 01-25-2012


In The Matter Of: The Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-36, as amended

In The Matter Of: A Plan of Compromise or Arrangement of North End United Housing Co-operative Ltd., a body corporate under the laws of the Province of Nova Scotia


Before The Hon. Justice McDougall


INITIAL ORDER


"UPON READING the Ex Parte Application filed by the Applicant pursuant to the Act;


"AND UPON READING the Affidavit of Jonathan Hannam swarn on the 17th day of January, 2012;


"AND UPON NOTING the consent of Grant Thornton Limited to act as Monitor for the business and financial affairs of the Applicant;"...

"Service"


1. "THAT this application is properly brought ex parte and that no service thereof was required. This Application is properly returnable today. Notice of this Order shall be provided to creditors as required by paragraph 38 hereof."


"Application of this Order"

2. "THAT North End United Housing Co-operative Ltd. is a company to which the Act applies."


"Plan of Arrangement"

3. "THAT the Applicant shall have the authority to, and may, subject to further order of this Court, file with this Court a plan of compromise or arrangement (hereinafter referred to as the "Plan" between, inter alia, the Applicant and one or more classes of its secured and/or unsecured creditors as it deems appropriate."


Review all 12-pages or 45 paragraphs of the Court decision:

GRANTTHORNTON.CA

http://www.tinyurl.com/7kyw9ov


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review Court Files and Case Information in regards to North End Housing Co-operative Limited.


GRANTTHORNTON.CA                              

http://www.tinyurl.com/7u88hj3


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review Province of Nova Scotia, Department of Community Services ("DCS") and North End United Housing Co-operative Ltd. ("NEU") Oversight of Social Housing Assistance Repair Program, Government and Financial Sustainability Review August 10, 2011 that was prepared by Grant Thornton LLP.


The 54-page Oversight Review places blame for the NEU co-op debacle that is shared by the NEU Board of Directors, CHF Canada, and DCS.



GRANTTHORNTON.CA                                  

http://tinyurl.com/7dhaog5



*********************************************************

CHF Canada NewsBriefs, Nova Scotia Edition, Fall 2010


"A FOND FAREWELL"

"Warren Olson is leaving his position as the go-to-guy on housing for the Department of Communitty Services (DCS) where he established a reputation as a great friend and champion at Nova Scotia co-ops."


..."CHF Canada will miss Warren's support and initiative," says CHF Canada, Sector Development, Karla Skoutajn."--- "He has played a central role in fostering our positive and productive relationship with DCS."


CHFCANADA.COOP

http://tinyurl.com/ll764ar


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Awards at CHF Canada's 2010 AGM


"North End United Housing Co-op in Halifax receives Award for Best Practices"---"In recognition of their innovative work to merge four co-operatives into new vibrant co-operative housing community,"..."the merger has been a resounding sucess. Strong governance has been re-established, sound management is in place, repairs are going ahead and the membership has a renewed sense of community and a new vision for the future."


CHFCANADA.COOP                                 

http://www.tinyurl.com/668a8rr


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

North End United Housing Co-operative Ltd. Website:

http://www.tinyurl.com/7q8w8gr


---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Review some News Media coverage about North End United Housing Co-operative Ltd., in the links below:


CBC.CA

September 4, 2012

"Halifax co-op going into receivership"

http://www.tinyurl.com/9r88pko


METRONEWS.CA

August 28, 2012

By Ruth Davenport, Metro Halifax

"Halifax housing co-op heading into receivership"

http://www.tinyurl.com/8egvqm4


CBC.CA

August 28, 2012

"Deal to save housing co-op falls apart"

http://www.tinyurl.com/8gswpqz


OPENFILE.CA

June 15, 2012

Reported by Chris Benjamin

"Debt Forces North End Housing Co-op To Transfer Half Its Properties To Province"


"A report by the accounting firm Grant Thornton LLP divided the blame among the provincial Department of Community Services, the Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada, and NEU's board."

http://www.tinyurl.com/7l2ghey


CBC.CA

June 15, 2012

"Contractors angry with housing co-op offer"

http://www.tinyurl.com/7s8jx2e


OPENFILE.CA                                                                       

February 23, 2012                                                           

Reported by Chris Benjamin

"North End United Co-op Debacle Highlights Affordable Housing Problems"

http://www.tinyurl.com/6ooku6x


THECHRONICLEHERALD.CA

February 7, 2012

By Bruce Erskine, Business Reporter

"Creditors rap handling of co-op case"

http://www.tinyurl.com/7vnlt2h


CBC.CA                                                                                

January 18, 2012

"Housing Co-op files for creditor protection"

http://www.tinyurl.com/7xzhjsr


CBC.CA

March 24, 2011

"Co-op housing work unpaid: plumber"

http://www.tinyurl.com/5wv4bpg


NEWSWIRE.CA                                                                      

January 20, 2010

Co-operative Housing Federation of Canada                 

"The North End Housing Co-op, a new Nova Scotia housing co-op created by the merger of four existing co-ops, has received $3.1 million from provincial and federal stimulus funds for capital repairs and energy-conserving modifications."

http://www.tinyurl.com/4g6kh4p



Information noted above may be revised and/or deleted without prior notification



Ken Hummel, Administrator, CHIE